Macadamia Milk vs Cashew Milk: Which One’s Creamier, and Which One Wins for Gut Health?

If milk texture were a personality, macadamia would be the quiet luxury type—velvety, buttery, indulgent. Cashew is the reliable multitasker: gentle, smooth, always adaptable.

They both blend beautifully with berries, rawnola, or tahini-based dressings—but when it comes to digestion and nutrient depth, they part ways. Let’s break it down by texture, gut behavior, and when to use which pour.

Fat Content and Mouthfeel

Macadamia milk owes its thickness to its rich monounsaturated fat content—around 21 g per 1 cup (140 g) of nuts. That’s the same fatty acid family found in avocados and olive oil, which gives it its unmistakable richness.

Cashews offer closer to 12 g of fat per cup (140 g), but they come with a natural advantage: built-in lecithins. These compounds help emulsify your milk, keeping it smooth and cohesive without the need for constant stirring.

Feature	Macadamia Milk	Cashew Milk
Fat (per 140 g)	~21 g	~12 g
Mouthfeel	Thick, creamy, subtly sweet	Smooth, lighter, gently nutty
Separation after 48h	May need a stir	Stays well blended
Flavor profile	Buttery, dessert-like	Mild, neutral, versatile

Macadamia milk is the one to reach for when you want full-body richness in your chia pudding or raw dessert. Cashew shines when you want something soft on your stomach that plays well with both sweet and savory flavors.

Gut Reaction: Which One’s Gentler?

Gut Reaction: Which One’s Gentler?

Let’s talk digestion.

Cashew milk has a reputation for playing nice with sensitive systems—and it earns it. When soaked properly and pressed fresh, cashews are smooth operators. They’re easy on the gut, rich in magnesium (which helps your bowels move like they mean it), and naturally low in digestive drama. If your belly’s been feeling fragile or you’re in a pre-period fog, cashew’s your guy.

Macadamia milk, meanwhile, doesn’t beg for attention—but it shows up strong. While it’s richer in fat, it’s not heavy. In fact, its mellow profile makes it ideal when you need a creamy milk that satisfies without triggering a full symphony of gut reactions. Think of it as the milk that minds its own business while still making you feel like you’ve had something indulgent.

Also worth noting: neither of these nuts are high on the internal chaos scale. No mystery bloating. No wild swings. Just smooth, clean, usable fat that gives your digestive system a chance to exhale.

Nutrient	Macadamia	Cashew	Gut Relevance
Magnesium	Moderate	High	Muscle + nerve function
Copper	High	Moderate	Enzyme support, collagen production
Texture impact	Heavier	Lighter	Choose based on gut mood
Digestive vibe	Creamy but calm	Soft, clean, easygoing	Both offer smooth digestion without drama

If you tend to lean cautious with new foods, start with cashew milk. If you want richness without regret, macadamia’s got your back—and your belly.

When to Rotate for Maximum Benefit

Rotation keeps your pour purposeful—and your body responsive. Alternating milks prevents overexposure to one type of nutrient or fat profile and helps support gut biodiversity. Here’s a smart way to approach the week:

• Macadamia days: Post-travel, post-bleed phase, skin-focused reset
• Cashew days: Luteal phase, post-workout, light breakfast days
• Both: Perfect in a weekly rotation to hit different nutrient notes

For more on rotation and your cycle, explore this guide on seed-based sipping.

If you’re making milk often—and especially if you’re rotating nuts throughout the week—a press that actually supports that rhythm can make all the difference. The Nama M1 is built for that kind of use: quiet, efficient, and able to handle everything from soaked cashews to dry macadamias without heating or breaking enzymes.

Is your countertop secretly hoping to showcase the M1? Smart thinking.
Use Discount Code PLANTPOWER to save on the Nama M1 nut milk maker and juicers.

Flavor Notes and Pairing Ideas

Macadamia milk has a richness that’s almost custardy—ideal in recipes where you want your milk to carry the flavor:

• Lucuma-spiked smoothie bowls
• Berry + tahini chia pudding
• Vanilla-nut dressing for raw zucchini noodles

Cashew milk, by contrast, is the background player that lets other ingredients sing:

• Turmeric ginger elixirs
• Light raw soups
• Raw mousse or herbal drinks that lean creamy but not sweet

Final Pour

These two milks do more than hydrate. They support your gut, nourish your skin, and let your kitchen habits stay diverse and intentional.

Macadamia for indulgence, cashew for balance—and both for better digestion when used wisely. You don’t need to choose one. You just need to pour like you mean it.

Let’s keep the pour going.